Book VS Cinema: 10 shields that are better than originals

Anonim

Hollywood promised to rent a movie on the book by Jesbe - a new favorite of the whole reading public. While the fans of Norwegian detectives worry, whether the Roman's filmmakers will not go away, pics.ru collects films for you, which turned out to be definitely not worse than books, and sometimes better.

"Forrest Gump"

For

That's whoever knew - a film that was firmly established in the ranking of the best films of all times, removed on the novel Winston Groom. Groom, a former warrior, who served in Vietnam, wrote several books and a bunch of boring historical essays. Paper "Forrest Gump" on three heads below brilliant adaptation.

"Crimson Petal and White"

Bagr.

A rare case when deciding what is better - novel or film is very difficult. Perhaps because the mini-series eponymous, filmed in 2011 for the Air Force for the Book of Michel Faiter, repeats the original almost literally. The history of the Victorian prostitute candy, which came to success, was played by the most beautiful Romol of Garai and Chris O'Dudom, whom you love with the "HOME", and as a cherry on the cake - Gillian Anderson as a Friend Bandera.

"Redemption"

aton

And one more rare case. This is what it turns out when Ian Macuen writes a good book, which is immediately nominated for a buoy, and the young arrogant director drives her teeth and, having stamped with a young and beautiful shooting platform, removes a heartbreaking drama about the fact that the mince is impossible to turn back.

"Talented Mr. Ripley"

RIP2.

The book of Patricia Heismitt is definitely not exactly those that are read on one breath - the story will be touched and sound in the descriptions, and the heroes have the expressiveness of birch chiochoks. Only a steep plot saves this novel. The film release of Minghella is deprived of all the shortcomings of the original, besides there is a young Low, Matt Damon and Gwyneth Paltrow - Casting Dreams for any film of the 90s.

"The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes and Dr. Watson"

Sher

Forgive, Benedict, but we are talking about our old Soviet series with Vitaly Solomin and Vasily Livanov. As director, Igor Maslennikov managed to restore Victorian England literally on the knee, so that the British themselves still apply - a mystery. We must necessarily. But you should not reread. It is sad to recognize, but Conan Doyle is very average literature for high school students.

"The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo"

Drak.

The book of Sting Larsson is very good, but the paper men with her pages are very losing Daniel Craig and Rooney Mara - the best Bloomquist and Lisbeth Salander simply impossible to imagine.

"Sex in the big city"

CIT.

The main series of zero was removed on column Candace Bushnell in the New York Observer newspaper. Pretty sulfur column, must admit. Whether the translator SHALTURIL, whether the Candace itself is not lion thick, but read these notes is boring. In addition, half of the success of the series - Heroine's clothes, for which you can write the history of trendy trends.

"Toughie"

Krep.

Book of the Roderick Book of the same name is a very good form of militants in a soft cover, that is, the best among the worst. But the film is a real icon and the classic of the genre. From the original on the screen there are not so many - the actors improvised themselves, the scenario was added right between the dubs.

"Gone With the Wind"

Unes

Roman Margaret Mitchell, not say, great. In all senses - in volume, he is not inferior to the "war and the world", and to master such a brick of literature is not for everyone. The film with Vivien Lee and Clark Gablom is also not a short film, of course, but when the brain gets up to follow the peripetia of the life of Miss O'Hara, you can simply admire her outfits and arrows.

"The Shawshank Redemption"

Show.

Regarding the passing story of King "Rita Hayworth and Salvation from Schown" did not receive even a separate publication - she was shoved in the collection "Four Seasons". But Frank Darabont did a real candy from this scant material with Tim Robbins and Morgan Freeman. Without fools, this is the best film about shooting from prison.

Read more